Land2 min read

German Military Bars Some Chinese Cars From Sensitive Bases Over Spy Fears, Drops Chinese Drones

Some BYD, Nio and Geely cars are being kept out of sensitive Bundeswehr sites over concerns about their cameras and sensors, Der Spiegel reported. The Defense Ministry says the rules apply to connected cars site by site, and has confirmed it will replace its Chinese-made drones.

By Militrax ·

A silver BYD Atto 3 electric SUV parked on a city street.
A BYD Atto 3 electric SUV. BYD is one of the Chinese brands reported on lists of cars barred from sensitive Bundeswehr sites. File photo. Photo: Charles from Port Chester, New York (CC0)

German soldiers who drive certain Chinese cars to work are being told to park outside. Some models from BYD, Nio and Geely are being stopped at the gates of sensitive Bundeswehr sites over concerns about what their cameras and sensors could record, Der Spiegel first reported on November 10.

According to the magazine, lists circulating inside the Bundeswehr name specific Chinese models barred from facilities classified as security areas. Bloomberg, citing people familiar with a nonpublic counterintelligence assessment, reported that officials judged the risk of espionage through data picked up by drones and cars to be too high.

Not a brand ban, says Berlin

The Defense Ministry pushed back on the idea of a ban on brands. Spokesperson Col. Mitko Muller said on November 11 that the restriction covers connected vehicles in general and that local security officers set the rules site by site. A connected car could be kept out of one restricted zone but still allowed to park farther away from sensitive buildings.

That means there is no single published list, and the ministry has not said whether other brands are affected. Geely's reach in Germany goes well beyond its own badge, through Volvo, Polestar, Lynk & Co, Zeekr, Lotus and its joint ownership of Smart with Mercedes-Benz.

The ministry named cameras, microphones, radar and ultrasonic sensors as the concern. The hardware that helps a car park itself or watch a tired driver can, near a barracks, record layouts, movements and equipment.

Two German military police soldiers in high-visibility vests stand guard at a barracks.

German Feldjager military police at a US Army garrison in Ansbach during Defender-Europe 21, May 2021. Local security officers decide which vehicles may enter Bundeswehr security areas. File photo.

Cars: precaution. Drones: confirmed

There is so far no public evidence that any affected car sent Bundeswehr data to Chinese intelligence, the Stuttgarter Zeitung reported; the measures are described as a precaution. Drones are a different story. Der Spiegel quoted an insider saying the military counterintelligence service MAD found forensic traces of a possible data outflow in Chinese-made drones used by the Bundeswehr. The ministry has not confirmed that, but it has confirmed the decision: "no Chinese models will be used anymore and existing systems will be replaced by national or European products." The Bundeswehr reportedly has thousands of Chinese drones in use.

Why it matters

Germany is not alone. Poland restricted Chinese-made vehicles at military sites in February, the US military barred privately owned BYD vehicles from Kadena Air Base in Japan in October, and in Norway Chinese-owned rental cars recorded a military exercise. Modern cars are rolling sensor platforms that send data home, and the same logic that removed Huawei from 5G networks is now reaching parking lots. The Defense Ministry says it is writing comprehensive rules for connected vehicles on its bases.

Newsletter · Free every Sunday

The week in defense, in five minutes.

Militrax Defense Review issue 1 cover

Defense Review · Issue 01

The Drone Age Arrives

Read it free →

Read Next